|
TIMES OF INDIA
Kolkata
Book Fair banned
Jan
29. 2008. [
more
]
KOLKATA:
Less than 24 hours before its inauguration, Calcutta
High Court has banned the 33rd Kolkata Book Fair from
being held on the Park Circus maidan on environmental
grounds. The fair was to be held from January 29 to
February 10.
The
verdict forced the Publishers and Booksellers Guild
to do a rethink on the issue and came as a major embarrassment
to Kolkata Municipal Corporation, which had taken the
initiative to allow the fair to be held at the Park
Circus maidan. It was also a blow to the state government,
which gave tacit support to the entire effort.
The
organizers are in disarray at the turn of events. "There
is a difference of opinion in the guild's book fair
committee about where to hold the fair. At this moment,
we aren't looking for any alternative venue. Where's
the guarantee the new venue won't bring in another PIL?
We leave it to the city people to decide," said guild
secretary Tridib Chattopadhyay.
The
loss of face apart, the publishers, decorators and the
guild could lose crores if the fair is not held. The
guild may have to apply for fresh dates from the international
body of book fair organizers.

Christopher
Merrill launching the ceremonial book fair.
Chief
minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee, an avid book-lover,
said the verdict was "unfortunate".
The
guild and KMC, which granted permission, were pulled
up by the green Bench of Chief Justice S S Nijjar and
Justice Pinaki Chandra Ghosh. The guild has been asked
to restore the ground to its original form and hand
it over to KMC at the earliest.
|

Joy Harjo, Suji Kim, Nathalie Handal
& Carolyn Forche in India
Setting
aside the permissions granted by Kolkata Police and
the fire services, the court observed that apart from
posing a threat to the environment, holding the fair
at the Park Circus maidan would violate Article 14 (equality
in the eye of the law) and Article 21 (right to life
that includes right to live in a pollution-free environment).
The
Bench held that holding the fair would violate laws
relating to air pollution, noise pollution and other
environmental laws. Pulling up KMC for granting permission
to the organizers, it said the civic body did not consider
the pollution aspect before giving its go-ahead.
The
verdict drew a sharp reaction from mayor Bikash Ranjan
Bhattacharya, who said it went against the wishes of
the majority. "Some people might benefit from this order,
but it is a tremendous blow to the city's image. If
there were any technical errors on KMC's part, then
the fair could have been deferred instead of being banned.
If pollution is the determining factor, then the high
court should also be closed down, considering the high
level of vehicular pollution in the court's vicinity,"
Bhattacharya said.
International delegates who've arrived here have been
told about the uncertainty the event faces.
In
2007, when a similar court order had booted the fair
out of the Maidan, sports minister Subhas Chakraborty
had come in as the saviour, offering Salt Lake stadium
as the venue. But the state government is yet to come
up with a lifeline for the guild this time.
The
court verdict is a culmination of a long-drawn battle
between the environmentalists and the state on holding
fairs at the Maidan, close to Victoria Memorial. In
November 2003, the state had assured the court all fairs
would be shifted from the Maidan and a permanent complex
would come up on the Eastern Metropolitan Bypass.
|